Issue - meetings

To consider the report of the Head of Planning and Building Control.

(Report circulated)

CouncillorWadham declared a personal interest as he knows the objector.

The Head of Planning and Building Control presented the report informing Members of an objection that had been received by the Council to Exeter City Council Tree Preservation Order No. 621 (Bridge End, 39 Elm Grove Road, Topsham, Exeter) 2010.

 Members were informed that Topsham Tree Warden supported confirmation of the Tree Preservation Order.

Mrs Stevenson-Rowe spoke against the Tree Preservation Order. She raised the following points:-

• the property had been in the family for years
• the tree was positioned between an extension and garage
• the crown was raised 15 years ago
• was concerned that the tree could cause damage or even loss of life if branches were lost
• this tree did not have enough amenity value to warrant a Tree Preservation Order
• two neighbours supported the felling of the tree
• the tree had outgrown its location
• if the tree was removed she would replant a more suitable tree in its place.

Members were of the opinion that the tree did not have any amenity value and that it had out grown its location. They acknowledged that the objector had stated that they would replace the tree should it be felled.

RESOLVED that the order not be confirmed.

(Report circulated)