Issue - meetings

To consider the report of the Head of Parking, Engineering and Business Support.

Scrutiny Committee - Economy considered the report at their meeting on 3 September 2009 and their comments will be reported. 

(Report circulated)

The report of the Head of Parking, Engineering and Business Support was submitted, seeking Members’ views on a motion to withdraw Sunday charges in all City Council car parks. The motion had been considered by Scrutiny Committee – Economy at their meeting on 3 September 2009 and they had referred their comments to this Committee to enable Executive to reach an informed decision.

The Director Economy and Development reported that if the revenue from Sunday parking was lost, the Council would need to identify other savings to meet the predicted shortfall of approximately £150,000. He considered that the Sunday parking tariff was already set at a competitive rate and doubted whether the proposal would achieve the desired effect of boosting Sunday trade in the City.

Members noted the range of views expressed by Scrutiny Committee - Economy but considered that the proposal was unlikely to achieve its stated objective and should not be pursued in the context of the budgetary situation facing the Council. 

Executive resolved that no change be made to the Sunday parking tariff scheme.

The report of the Head of Parking, Engineering and Business Support was submitted, seeking Members’ views on a motion to withdraw Sunday charges in all City Council car parks. The motion had been considered by Scrutiny Committee – Economy at their meeting on 3 September 2009 and they had referred their comments to this Committee to enable Executive to reach an informed decision.

The Director Economy and Development reported that if the revenue from Sunday parking was lost, the Council would need to identify other savings to meet the predicted shortfall of approximately £150,000. He considered that the Sunday parking tariff was already set at a competitive rate and doubted whether the proposal would achieve the desired effect of boosting Sunday trade in the City.

Members noted the range of views expressed by Scrutiny Committee - Economy but considered that the proposal was unlikely to achieve its stated objective and should not be pursued in the context of the budgetary situation facing the Council. 

RESOLVED that no change be made to the Sunday parking tariff scheme.

(Report circulated)

To receive the report of the Head of Parking, Engineering and Business Support – report circulated

Councillor Newby attended the meeting and spoke on this item under Standing Order 45.

The report of the Head of Parking, Engineering and Business Support was presented, and sought the views of Members of the Scrutiny Committee – Economy, following referral of a Motion submitted to Council on 14 July 2009 by Councillor Newby.  He had called for the withdrawal of Sunday charges in all of the City Council car parks in an effort to help combat the effects of the recession on the local economy.

The Director outlined the financial implications of such an action and the challenging budgetary position currently faced by the City Council. He advised that if the revenue from the Sunday tariff were removed, then other proposals would have to be brought forward to address a predicted shortfall of approximately £150,000. He outlined the procedure stating that, should there be Member support for the Motion, the matter would be referred to Executive for a final decision.

Councillor Newby commented on a number of issues, which he felt made his Motion a valid proposition, including the impact of vacant units in the city centre; the lack of a Sunday Park and Ride service and a past example of when car parking charges were removed on some Sundays preceding Christmas 2008.  He had also spoken to the Chair of the Exeter Chamber of Commerce, who supported his stance and who asked if there might be a repeat of the free Sunday Christmas parking this year.

The Director responded to the points raised, advising that last year’s suspension of  tariffs in a number of car parks on three Sundays preceding Christmas, related to a VAT reduction, and was a one off initiative. The Park and Ride Scheme was operated by Devon County Council, and Stagecoach and there was no Sunday Park and Ride service from Matford, due to the weekly Sunday Market and Car Boot sale. He also confirmed that officers had made an accurate survey of the number of vacant retail units in the city centre, which was still running at 8% of all units, which compared favourably nationally with other cities.

During a lengthy discussion, Members expressed a mix of views for and against the proposal and made the following comments:-

• Actual detail of the research evidence relating to parking charges would have been useful.
• There appeared to be some inconsistency in the measures that could help the local economy, and the long term effectiveness of the funding of the recent recession initiatives which had been possible despite the current financial position.
• Recognition that Sunday was now a day of trade, so perhaps this was the opportunity to address the level of public transport available on Sundays.
• Even if car parking charges were removed, corresponding trade levels might not increase, and it was still national retailers who traded predominantly on Sundays as opposed to local businesses.
• It was no longer appropriate to have any different arrangements for Sunday parking, which was now part of the seven  ...  view the full minutes text for item 32